Talismans not dropping at all

I was wondering whether you need to use tame on possessed monsters for a talisman to drop? I only ever found like 5 of them or so on my first character in this league when I used tame. Since then I have killed who knows how many whisps on a total of 4 character levelled up to 90 and not found any. My loot filter is the same. Is that normal?

I have found like 15 sacred (relic / orange) wisps, and none dropped the talisman (fox / rabbit). I don't know what I'm doing wrong here.